This is my third piece of feedback. Here I am receiving feedback from a two men aged 46 years of age. I have also got feedback from 2 women, aged 48 and 37. The men are my primary target audience due to Garbage's prime time was in the 1980's when these participants were 20 years of age. The feedback given was mainly positive; however, some of the shots of the music video were stated as being too long therefore, I will be shortening these down and filling the gaps in with other footage that I have got from the shooting days that I have not used yet. Also some constructive criticism was that instead of some of the shots going from light to dark t hen light back to dark at the end, the continuity and the narrative would be clearer if the beginning of the music video was in day light and then towards the end it stayed dark. Also the transition between the light day time and dark night time may need to be smoother and more continuous. However, the story line was clear and they enjoyed the overall shots and they mentioned that it looked like a professional music video. One of the 46 year old men has been in band over the last 20 years and he edits his music videos; he stated that from his experience that my music looked more professional than many unprofessional music videos he has ever seen.
Below is some audience feedback from the first rough cut and also the second brought cut. I asked two friends aged 18 to watch and give me feedback on how to improve and what they liked about the music video.
Here Josh and Sophie are talking about how they like the music video. Later on i asked them if they thought anything could be improved. Josh mentioned that the shot of the female walking into the lake could be shorter and that it lasts a long time. However, they both enjoyed the shot of the female turing in slow motion (slow motion recap done on premier).
This is the second audience feedback that i was given from them today. Here, they are watching the second rough cut. Both of these rough cuts don't involve much editing; but mainly just clips put together. There has been no colour balancing; however, i have overplayed one of the shots of the church onto a close rotating shot of the female. This is as much editing of the clips that i have don't so far. Overall the feedback from these two people isn't specifically in the detail that i wanted; however, form this i am going to shorten some clips and edit the footage more. The audience feedback here is from my secondary audience and therefore, i will be getting more feedback from by primary audience (men ages 28-40) in the future once i have added some colour balance and editing.